Rev. James S. Murphy (1846-1849)
Rev. Joseph Meister (1849-1853)
Rev. Joseph Blaarer (1853-1854)
Rev. William Walsh (1854-1863)
Rev. Jacob Meller (1863-1875)
Rev. Henry Meurs (1875-1876)
Msgr. Otto J. S. Hoog (1876-1904)
Msgr. Joseph Selinger, D.D. (1904-1934)
Msgr. Joseph A. Vogelweid, P.A. (1934-1969)
Rev. Norman J. Ahrens (1969-1972)
Rev. John W. Buchanan (1972-1977)
Rev. Kevin Gormley (1977-1985)
Rev. John H. Fischer (1985-1992)
Rev. Louis Dorn (1992-1994)
Rev. Donald W. Lammers (1994-Present)