It is clear from the above, that a number of factors, (respect
for parents, use of teaching strategies which were specified
earlier and teacher modelling) have all contributed to the
control group demonstrating the following:
- a greater respect for Jesus and the Church
- a greater appreciation of the relevance of Religious
Education in their lives
- a deeper understanding of true freedom - it is not a
subjective view of the world
- a deeper appreciation of the media's perception of the
Church
- a more encouraging response to Religious Truths which
cannot be seen - Jesus, Heaven, Miracles
- a move away from merely doubting or seeing as 'uncool'
things such as Mass attendance. Many are now unsure about
their previous views.
- A move away from a reverential attitude towards the music
industry
In general and in summary the results demonstrate
- student definition of coolness is not really accurate to
reality - their definition makes them very concerned
about self and yet they can be very altruistic and value
this altruism in others. Not only in that but also, 64% (50)
value belonging to a group but 64 % (81) value being
different to others. They value subjectivism 64% (25) and
yet are kind and do respect the rights of others, in
theory, if not in practice.
- They demonstrate they value Christian values which do not
have that label because they are so concerned with self.
Recommendations
- Educators, from Principals to the general teacher must understand
the impact of parents on students and gather support.
Perhaps we should be more active in trying to evangelise
parents? ('This is the only place I ever hear this
message' - 40% ( 50)
- students said clearly that they have an awareness of
people valuing different forms of spirituality -
49% (69) so here I agree with Crawford and Rossiter who
state that we need to be aware of this pluralism and
address it. (Crawford/Rossiter, 1993 p. ).
- They also are good at being critical of all forms of
authority - 49% (44) so why not harness this and be
critical of the media et. al and these other
religions other than just gliding over them.
- They also see praying to a God that can't be seen as
normal, at least 35% did (50). Teachers need not be
afraid of the surface antagonism demonstrated towards
prayer.
- Teaching strategies ( as indicated at the start of
this report) should be utilised to gain credibility
for the teacher and the subject.
- Teacher modelling is crucial. Teachers must be
confident in what they teach and seek answers when they
are not known. (56% (50) wondered "How does the
teacher know this?")
- Integrating faith and life through the community
service is crucial given the altruism, which it
fosters, and given the value students place on this. This
is not the only way, however, to foster students'
spiritual development. It is also through;
- Harnessing the qualities students possess innately
- the ability to 'vision an ideal world' (Slee, 1996.p 78)
energy to stand up for convictions, affiliation with
community, desire to search and question, musical
intelligence and a desire for true freedom, although they
may not articulate it as such (Leavey et.al, 1992.p 221).
- As the New Jersey Bishops have made clear ( Origins, 1992.p
92), "Today's society is immersed in a complex
culture that shapes its worldview. Most lives are media
centred. [We must] capture [students'] minds' with it.
This of course entails understanding how it works
and giving students the skills to appreciate its power
over them.
- We need to highlight the effects and existence of the
Culture of Death existing in our society so that
students can also say with Jean-Francois Mattei, "
You have the death penalty and keep a newborn alive
without a brain. You celebrate a clone and clone him."
(Gelman, 1995.p 78)
- Teachers should feel content to give students an
answer to why the above life issues are ethical
questions in the first place. This requires an adult
faith. Studying Kohlberg's method in a modified form is
an excellent start to highlighting the fact that people
face ethical questions and that they do so differently.
These questions will inevitably bring the issue of death
to a fore and this is an opportunity to bring Jesus
closer to the children and help them understand the
meaning of His death and the value of life. Then we can
apply a study of the fruits of certain decisions, which
are claimed to be anti-life. In the words of a famous man,
" You will know by their fruits."
- Catholic Schools, must do nothing to contradict their
mission by undermining RE with general Curriculum(
Leavey et.al, 1992.pp 217, 223). I specifically ask
Science, Health and Social Science teachers to be
critical of their sources of information and to be aware
of bias in all texts, and of content which needs to be
handled carefully.
- As Gallagher states, we need to meet our opponents ' on
the level of experience, imagination and spirituality',
through various prayer experiences (including time
for use of imagination and silence), community service,
creativity and an understanding that what they
participate in with regards to service (which they enjoy)
is evidence of a spirituality which is innate and natural.
No one can then really argue with experience. As Hill
states, Religious Education faces the challenge of
connecting spirituality with action, especially with
action for poor people" (Hill, 1988.p 112). If we
achieve this the Integration of Faith and Life in all
forms will render Christianity and Religious Education as
not only cool, but life transforming.
- We have a mandate to proclaim the 'mystery of
salvation' (which must by definition include sin and
forgiveness) and teach children to 'weigh moral values
with an upright conscience' (p. 639) The results of this
project demonstrate that the Catholic School can foster
an identity which works, through love, to a
'personal commitment to Jesus'' (Egan, 1988.p 29),to an
intimacy with Jesus that Pope John Paul II speaks
of (Egan, 1988.p 30) and to peace and justice in
our world through Evangelisation (Egan, 1988.p 32 ), but
only if we accept Hater's emphasis on 'conversion'. The
Catholic School must seek the conversion of hearts
through the formation of a clearly defined identity,
which comes from 'knowledge' and the practice, in
community, of the liturgical life of the church and the
beauty of its devotions; traditional AND engaging all the
senses and 'multiple intelligences' students have (Hill,
1988.p 105).
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abbot, W. S.J (Ed). (1966). The Documents of Vatican II.
London: Geoffrey Chapman
Crawford, M & Rossiter, G. (1993) Religious Education
and Changes In The Church. Word In Life, August, 1993.
Sydney.
Egan, Sr.J. (1988). Opting Out: Catholic Schools Today
. Herefordshire. Fowler Wright Books
Flynn, M. (1993). The Culture of Catholic Schools. A
study of Catholic School, 1972-1993. Homebush, NSW: St. Paul
Publications.
Hater, R.J. (1994). New Visions, New Directions. Tabor
Publishing. Texas.
Origins. (1992). Catechetical Ministry Attuned to the Signs
of the Times. Origins. Vol.22: No.17
Pope John Paul II. (1992). Catechism of The Catholic Church
(1994). Official edition for Australia and New Zealand. Homebush,
NSW: St. Paul Publications
Lenihan, E (1993). Theology of Children. Word of
Life. May
Gallagher, M (1997). Clashing Symbols. Dartyon. Longman and
Todd
Slee, (1996): Further on From Fowler.
Adler: Clone Hype